A Self Assessment bill is a reconciliation, so it can come out in your favour. The return adds up your tax for the year and subtracts everything already paid: tax taken from pay, CIS deductions, and the two payments on account. If that sum goes below zero, you have overpaid.
How an overpayment arises
The usual causes are:
- Payments on account larger than this year's bill. They are based on last year's tax. If your profit fell, you paid too much in advance. See payments on account.
- Tax deducted at source above your real tax. For example CIS deductions at 20% or 30% on a low profit, as in our CIS tax refund guide, or PAYE tax that was too high.
- Allowances and reliefs claimed on the return, such as job expenses or Marriage Allowance, that reduce the bill below what was paid.
The checker at tax refund checker compares payments with the bill for you.
How HMRC repays
gov.uk's page on claiming a Self Assessment tax refund says a refund may show as pending in your online tax account, which means it has been created but still needs to be approved and paid. gov.uk gives no timings there and points to its guidance on when to expect a reply.
Two details matter:
- Set-off. If you have tax due in the next 45 days, such as a payment on account, the money is deducted from the tax you owe instead of being refunded.
- Bank details. If you amend a paper return, HMRC pays a refund into your bank account if you included your bank details. The Self Assessment return has a section for the account you want a repayment sent to.
Late filing is penalised even when you are due money: the £100 penalty applies if you are due a refund, as our penalties guide explains. File on time, even if the answer is a refund.
Reducing payments on account
If you expect a lower bill this year, do not wait for a refund. gov.uk says you can ask HMRC to reduce your payments on account:
- Online: sign in to your online account, view your latest Self Assessment return, then select Reduce payments on account.
- By post: send form SA303 to your tax office.
You must state the amount you expect to owe so HMRC can recalculate. If the bill turns out higher, you are charged interest on the difference, so reduce only on a sound basis, such as a lost contract or a one-off gain last year.
Correcting a past return
If you find you paid too much on a return already filed, gov.uk's corrections guidance gives two routes:
- Amend the return within 12 months of the Self Assessment deadline, online or on paper. For 2024/25 that is usually 31 January 2027. Our amending a return guide has the steps.
- Overpayment relief after that window: you can claim up to 4 years after the end of the tax year it relates to. You write to HMRC with a statement that you are claiming overpayment relief, the tax year and why you overpaid, the amount and whether you appealed it before, and a declaration you sign yourself. No one else, including a tax agent, can sign it. A claim missing any of that is rejected.
A worked example
A sole trader paid two payments on account of £1,500 each, £3,000 in all, on last year's bill. This year's profit fell and the bill after tax deducted elsewhere is £2,200. The overpayment is £800. If a payment on account falls due within 45 days, HMRC may set the £800 against it. The sole trader could have cut the payments earlier with SA303.
How ac-co helps
ac-co drafts your SA100 from your bank, books and HMRC data and shows the full tax computation before you approve it, including whether it comes out as tax due or tax overpaid. HMRC calculates the final position and pays any repayment; ac-co does not receive refunds.